Immigration: Trump’s Success at the Border Creates a New Political Problem

WASHINGTON – Immigration was among the issues that brought Donald Trump back to the White House. Just over a month before the American midterm elections on November 3, 2026, however, the political debate has changed fundamentally. The number of illegal border crossings has fallen dramatically compared with the years of the Biden administration. The southern border, which in 2023 and 2024 regularly produced images of overcrowded reception facilities and large groups of migrants, is therefore no longer at the center of the daily political debate. Instead, the dispute now concerns the second phase of Trump’s immigration policy: mass deportations, ICE raids in the interior, detention centers, accelerated proceedings in immigration courts and the question of which rule-of-law limits apply to the authorities.

This has also changed the political landscape ahead of the midterms. Republicans can point to a significant decline in border crossings and present it as one of the most important successes of the second Trump administration. At the same time, criticism is growing of the way Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE, carries out deportations and arrests. Democrats, for their part, find themselves in a complicated position: many of their candidates do not want to return to the migration policy of the Biden years and support effective control of the border. They are therefore increasingly focusing their criticism on arrests of migrants without criminal records, access to lawyers, the treatment of families and children, and the constitutional limits of accelerated deportation proceedings.

A dispute over whether the border must be controlled has thus increasingly become a dispute over how immigration law should be enforced inside the United States.

At the same time, current polls show that migration has lost importance for voters overall. According to an analysis published by Axios on October 1, immigration was one of the country’s most important political issues two years ago. Now the cost of living and economic questions dominate. Erik Iverson, a Republican pollster who works with the Senate Republicans’ campaign apparatus, said immigration had dropped from a top-three issue to a figure “way down the list now, in single digits.”

This does not mean that migration has become irrelevant for the midterms. On the contrary: precisely because the situation at the border itself appears less dramatic, the political impact of the issue is now increasingly determined by enforcement policy in the interior.

The Border Is No Longer the Same Political Weak Point

The most important prerequisite for understanding the current debate is the changed situation at the southern border.

Since January 2025, the Trump administration has implemented a series of measures to restrict illegal migration and access to the asylum system. The administration deployed additional resources at the border, tightened enforcement of immigration law and accelerated deportations. The White House attributes the decline in illegal border crossings to these policies and describes the situation as a historic success. According to the White House, for months no migrant who illegally crossed the border was released into the United States after being apprehended. The administration also states that more than 605,000 people have been deported since Trump’s return to office; according to government figures, a further 1.9 million have left the country on their own. These figures are government statements and should be understood as such.

Regardless of the political assessment, it is clear that the number of illegal border crossings has fallen significantly from the peak levels during the Biden administration. Republican pollsters, too, see this as a reason why the issue has lost urgency among voters. Republican pollster Brent Buchanan put it this way to Axios: many Republican voters are less concerned with migration because they no longer perceive the problem on a daily basis.

The Republican Party thus finds itself in an unusual situation. Politically, it has partly defused one of its most important campaign issues by changing the situation that originally made this issue so effective. One Republican pollster described this phenomenon to Axios as being a “victim of your own success.” For Trump, this is strategically relevant. His presidential campaigns have been closely tied to immigration and border security since 2015. In the 2024 campaign, Republicans were able to point to the high number of border crossings during the Biden administration and hold the administration at the time directly responsible.

In 2026, this argument no longer works in the same way. Trump himself has now controlled the executive branch for more than a year and a half. The border is significantly calmer. At the same time, the consequences of his own enforcement policy have become visible.

From the Border to ICE

The decisive arena of immigration policy therefore increasingly lies hundreds or thousands of kilometers away from Mexico. ICE has massively expanded its activities in the interior.

According to government data analyzed by Reuters, the number of arrests by ICE rose to almost 51,000 in August. This marked a new record for the third month in a row. The number of deportations, however, did not grow at the same pace. Most recently, it stood at around 1,200 people per day. This difference is politically and legally significant.

An increasing share of the people arrested by ICE have no criminal conviction or have ongoing immigration proceedings. According to the data analyzed by Reuters, people with criminal convictions accounted for less than a quarter of ICE arrests in July. Many of those arrested have pending asylum cases, green card applications or other legal proceedings that can complicate or prevent immediate deportation. This is precisely where the central political conflict begins.

The Trump administration argues that violations of immigration law must in principle be enforced and that ICE needs sufficient powers to do so. Democratic politicians do not fundamentally dispute the federal government’s authority to enforce immigration law. They accuse the administration, however, of blurring the line between the targeted arrest of dangerous criminals and a sweeping deportation campaign. This dispute could be observed directly on the floor of the US Senate on September 30.

Jim Banks: “ICE needs to be allowed to enforce the law”

Republican Senator Jim Banks of Indiana on Wednesday blocked a push by Democratic Senator Chris Murphy of Connecticut. Murphy wanted to prevent ICE, Border Patrol and other agencies of the Department of Homeland Security from carrying out immigration enforcement at school bus stops. Banks argued that such a restriction would hamper ICE’s work.

“This is just another attempt by Democrats to stop ICE from doing their job and enforcing our immigration laws,” Banks said in the Senate on September 30.

The Republican pointed to crimes that, according to him, had been committed by people without legal status in Indiana. He also referred to a five-day ICE operation in his state in which 426 people were arrested. Banks declared: “ICE is not the enemy here.” His political conclusion was unequivocal: “ICE needs to be allowed to enforce the law wherever it takes them.”

Banks’ argument exemplifies the Republican campaign strategy. The party is trying to continue linking immigration closely to public safety, crime and state authority. Individual serious crimes committed by migrants are used as an argument for not restricting ICE’s options. Democrats counter that individual cases of serious crime do not justify subjecting migrants without criminal records or with ongoing legal proceedings to the same enforcement measures.

Chris Murphy Wants to Keep Children Out of ICE Operations

Murphy’s legislative initiative also shows how the Democratic strategy has changed. The senator from Connecticut did not call for abolishing ICE or stopping all deportations. Instead, he wanted to protect certain locations, including school bus stops, from immigration operations.

The background was ICE operations in Connecticut in which, according to Murphy, parents were arrested in the presence of their children. As early as September 22, Murphy had called on Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin to account for this.

“Children should not have to witness their parents being brutally arrested for civil immigration offenses,” Murphy stated. On September 30, Murphy finally tried to have his legislation passed in the Senate through an expedited procedure. Banks objected and blocked the move. The dispute shows the two political perspectives in almost textbook fashion. For Banks, the question is whether federal officers may enforce immigration laws wherever wanted persons are located. For Murphy, the question is whether law enforcement must have limits when children or particularly sensitive locations are affected.

Both sides are thus talking about “safety,” but mean different forms of it: Republicans focus on public safety through deportation and prosecution; Democrats increasingly on protection against disproportionate government action and due process.

Tensions Even Within the Republican Party

It is notable that the debate has now also become more complicated within the Republican Party. Senator Jim Justice of West Virginia felt compelled on September 30 to explicitly clarify his position on immigration policy. “I support President Trump’s immigration strategy, full stop,” Justice declared. The senator praised developments at the border and said ICE must continue to focus particularly on people who pose a danger to American communities. Justice said: “Violent criminals, drug traffickers, gang members and others who threaten our communities should be identified, arrested and removed.”

This wording is politically interesting. Justice explicitly supports Trump’s immigration agenda but at the same time emphasizes a focus on criminals and people who pose a danger. Precisely this question, who specifically should be the target of deportation policy, is increasingly becoming one of the decisive dividing lines in the public debate. The administration takes the fundamental position that people without lawful status can be deported. Critics, by contrast, call for stronger prioritization of dangerous criminals.

The Problem of Mass Deportations

During the presidential campaign, Trump had announced a large-scale deportation of people without legal status. In his second term, the infrastructure required for this has been expanded considerably. But implementation is running up against practical and legal limits. Reuters reported in mid-September that ICE arrests are rising much faster than actual deportations. Almost 51,000 arrests in August did not lead to a comparable increase in deportations. These stagnated at around 1,200 per day. One reason is the composition of those arrested.

People with existing deportation orders and no further legal claims can be deported relatively quickly. It becomes more difficult with people who have pending asylum applications, applications for permanent residence or other proceedings. Reuters described, for example, cases of migrants without criminal records who were pursuing a path to legal status through family members and were nevertheless arrested. Added to this are logistical difficulties.

Not every country of origin accepts an unlimited number of deportation flights. Aircraft must be organized. Courts can halt deportations. Lawyers can file appeals. And people with ongoing proceedings sometimes have rights that prevent immediate removal from the country. The Trump administration is therefore trying to create new avenues for faster deportations. One of these is deportations to so-called third countries.

Supreme Court Strengthens Trump’s Deportation Policy for Now

On September 29, only a few weeks before the midterms, the administration achieved a significant legal success in this area. The Supreme Court provisionally allowed the Trump administration to resume deporting migrants to countries that are not their countries of origin. The court thereby suspended a ruling by federal judge Brian Murphy, who had declared the Department of Homeland Security’s policy unlawful. The final decision, however, is still pending. The Supreme Court will hear the case in December.

According to human rights organizations, more than 25,000 migrants have already been deported to 29 third countries under this policy. The majority were taken to Mexico. Other deportations went to South Sudan, Uganda, Equatorial Guinea, Liberia and the Central African Republic, among others. The administration describes this option as an important instrument when migrants cannot be returned to their country of origin. The Justice Department told the court that third-country deportations are an “essential tool,” particularly for removing certain foreign criminals.

The plaintiffs argue, by contrast, that long-term residents without criminal records are also affected and that people could be sent to states where they face persecution or mistreatment. The legal core of the dispute therefore does not concern the fundamental authority to deport. It is about which procedural rights an affected person has before the government sends them to a third country. Immigration policy has thus also become a constitutional debate.

Democratic Senators Put “Due Process” at the Center

This development explains why Democratic senators are increasingly linking their criticism to the term “due process,” the constitutional right to a fair procedure. On September 30, Democratic Senators Ron Wyden and Jeff Merkley of Oregon attacked the administration over accelerated proceedings in immigration courts. Together with several Democratic representatives, they criticized so-called “mega master hearings,” in which numerous immigration cases are dealt with in court within a short period of time.

The politicians stated: “This unwarranted blitzkrieg of assaults on justice and fair treatment raises serious constitutional concerns.”

According to their account, those affected sometimes receive new court dates at short notice and have to arrange for lawyers within a very short time. The senators therefore called for longer lead times, individual proceedings and better access to legal representation, among other things. Their central demand is: “Immigration court proceedings must uphold fairness and rule of law.”

The Democratic arguments thus differ from the political debate of the Biden years. Back then, Democrats mainly had to defend themselves against the accusation of not adequately controlling the southern border.

In 2026, they are instead increasingly trying to distinguish between border security and the treatment of migrants already in the country. The core message is: border control, yes, but deportations and arrests must follow the rule of law.

Temporary Protection Also Becomes a Point of Conflict

Another point of contention is Temporary Protected Status, or TPS. This program allows people from certain countries experiencing war, natural disasters or other extraordinary conditions to live and work temporarily in the United States. The Trump administration has ended or restricted this protection for various groups.

On September 29, Democratic Senators Dick Durbin, Chris Van Hollen and Alex Padilla held a forum on the issue in the Senate. Durbin accused the administration of pushing people who have lived in the US for many years toward deportation by ending TPS programs. For Republicans, by contrast, what matters is that “temporary” must not automatically mean “permanent.” The administration argues in principle that protection programs can be ended if the conditions are no longer met or if the government reassesses the countries in question.

Here, too, the fundamental political dividing line is evident. Republicans place greater emphasis on enforcing existing immigration law and the powers of the executive. Democrats focus more on individual circumstances, existing family and economic ties, and procedural rights.

Immigration Has Become Politically More Complicated for Trump

It is particularly striking that Trump himself now acknowledges the political difficulties of his immigration agenda. At a Hispanic Heritage Month event at the White House on September 30, the president spoke about the administration facing contradictory expectations on immigration policy. On the one hand, an important part of his political base demands the most rigorous deportation policy possible. On the other hand, individual ICE operations and arrests trigger criticism, including in conservative communities and industries that depend on foreign workers.

This tension is particularly relevant for the midterms. In 2024, Trump gained significant support among Hispanic voters compared with previous Republican candidates. Part of this success was based on the fact that immigration policy is by no means viewed uniformly within the Latino population. Many Hispanic Americans support stronger border control or stricter rules against illegal migration.

But support for border controls does not automatically mean support for every form of ICE operation. This is precisely where the political risk lies for Republicans.

Public Opinion Is Shifting

Current polls show a remarkable change. According to the data analyzed by Axios on October 1, Trump’s rating on immigration policy is significantly worse than at the start of his second term. In an Ipsos survey from the end of August, disapproval of his immigration policy stood at 58 percent. At the start of his term, it had been 38 percent.

A September New York Times/Siena poll was particularly noteworthy. In it, Democrats led Republicans 51 to 45 percent in trust on immigration policy. Other polls, however, still see Republicans ahead. It would therefore be wrong to derive a lasting partisan advantage from a single survey. Another finding is considerably more stable: immigration is no longer the most important problem for many voters.

In Michigan, only 14 percent of voters named migration as their most important issue. In Ohio, 25 percent named immigration among their top three problems. The economy and inflation together accounted for 70 percent there. This changes the strategic importance of the issue. In 2024, the Republican Party was able to use migration as a national crisis issue. In 2026, this works only to a limited extent.

The Republican Advantage Nevertheless Remains

This does not mean that Republicans have lost the issue. Border security and public safety remain among the areas in which a significant share of voters trust Republican candidates. In individual races, immigration can therefore still be decisive. The issue is particularly effective where Republican candidates link migration with crime or economic burden.

Senator Banks demonstrated this strategy on September 30. Instead of talking abstractly about immigration figures, he named specific violent crimes and deaths in Indiana. His conclusion: “The madness needs to end.”

Such messages are aimed primarily at conservative and less regular Trump voters who need to be mobilized in midterm elections. Republicans can also point to a visibly real difference from the Biden era: the situation at the southern border has changed. This makes it harder for Democrats to portray Trump’s entire policy as a failure.

Democrats Have Shifted Their Position, Too

The Democratic Party of 2026 also differs markedly in its messaging from the party that debated immigration in 2020 or 2021. Calls for the complete abolition of ICE are far less central in the national Democratic campaign.

Many Democratic candidates now explicitly accept the need for a controlled border. The dispute focuses more on which methods ICE may use and which groups of people should have priority for deportation. This is also a response to the political experience of the Biden years.

The high number of border crossings damaged Democrats considerably. A return to a message that voters could understand as a lack of border control would therefore be politically risky. Instead, Democrats are trying to formulate a middle course: a secure border and consistent action against dangerous criminals, combined with protection of due process and restrictions on ICE at sensitive locations.

The Republican counterargument is that such restrictions would hinder the practical enforcement of the law. Banks summed up this argument when he described Murphy’s proposal as an attempt to create so-called “sanctuary bus stops.”

The Debate over ICE Becomes the Real Campaign Issue

The central question of the midterms is thus shifting. It is no longer exclusively: who can secure the southern border? It is increasingly: what does a secure border mean for the millions of people without permanent legal status who already live in the United States? Should ICE in principle be able to arrest everyone who is in the country without lawful status? Or should dangerous criminals have priority? Should ICE be allowed to make arrests at schools, bus stops, courts or other sensitive locations?

How much time must a migrant be given to find a lawyer? What rights exist before deportation to a country of which the person is not even a citizen? And how far may a government go to increase deportation numbers? These questions are far more difficult to reduce to a simple slogan than the demand for a secure border.

The Deportation System Is Reaching Practical Limits

Added to this is a problem that is often less visible in the campaign: even an administration that wants to deport as many people as possible cannot do so without limit. The almost 51,000 ICE arrests in August show the enormous expansion of enforcement. The simultaneously relatively stable figure of around 1,200 deportations per day, however, shows the limits of this system.

Arrests are not the same as deportations. Between an arrest by ICE and actual removal from the United States, there can be immigration courts, asylum proceedings, applications for legal status, appeals and practical questions of repatriation. Particularly in the case of people without criminal convictions or with ongoing proceedings, it is therefore becoming apparent that an expansion of arrests does not automatically lead to a proportional increase in deportations.

This creates double pressure for the administration. On the one hand, President Trump has promised his supporters a far-reaching deportation policy. On the other hand, this policy must be implemented within a system in which courts, procedural rights, available detention capacity, deportation flights and the cooperation of other states set concrete limits.

Third-country deportations show how the administration is trying to push these limits. The Supreme Court’s provisional ruling of September 29 initially strengthens the executive’s room for maneuver. Because the final decision is still pending and the case is to be heard in December, however, it remains open how far this room for maneuver will extend in the long term.

This practical dimension is important for the midterms. The political debate will not be measured solely by how many people ICE arrests. What also matters is whether the administration can actually implement its announced policy, and whether the means employed hold up in court.

A New Political Problem After Success at the Border

The immigration debate is thus returning to the campaign in a changed form a few weeks before November 3. Republicans can point to the sharp decline in illegal border crossings. The images of a southern border out of control that shaped the 2024 campaign no longer determine political perception in the same way. From the Trump administration’s perspective, this is a central success of its policy.

Yet precisely this success is changing the political debate. The less the border itself is perceived as an acute crisis, the more the consequences of enforcement policy in the interior move into focus: ICE raids, arrests of people without criminal records, the treatment of families and children, proceedings in immigration courts and deportations to third countries.

For Democrats, this shift opens up the opportunity to separate border security from criticism of the administration. Their leading voices no longer argue exclusively against a tough immigration policy, but focus on rule-of-law limits, priorities in deportations and the protection of sensitive locations. The clashes between Chris Murphy and Jim Banks and the demands of Ron Wyden and Jeff Merkley show this line particularly clearly.

For Republicans, by contrast, enforcement of immigration law remains the central point. Their argument is that a government cannot effectively enforce laws if ever new restrictions are imposed on the responsible agencies. Jim Banks expressed this position with his demand that ICE must be able to enforce the law wherever investigations lead the agency.

Voters in November therefore do not face the same immigration debate as in 2024. Back then, the dominant question was whether the federal government could bring the southern border under control. In 2026, it is increasingly about how far a government may go after it has significantly reduced border crossings. The decisive political tension therefore lies between two questions that cannot easily be separated: how rigorously should immigration law be enforced, and which legal, humanitarian and practical limits apply?

Therein lies Trump’s new political problem. The decline in border crossings removes part of the Democrats’ former vulnerability. At the same time, the expanded deportation policy forces Republicans to no longer talk only about border security but to defend the concrete consequences of their own policy. Whether immigration will once again become a decisive mobilizing issue on November 3 cannot be clearly derived from the available polls. What is clear, however, is that the debate has changed its arena. The political border no longer runs only along the Rio Grande. It now also runs through courts, schools, neighborhoods, detention centers and the question of how much power the state may exercise in enforcing immigration law.