Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124

Democracies are under pressure, and the questions societies must decide on are becoming ever more complex. What role should science play in this? This article argues for a tense yet productive relationship: science should inform politics, not replace it – close enough to society to stay relevant, and far enough from political interests to remain independent.
© Hereon/Bianca Seth, AI generated
Democracies are under pressure. Polarisation and disinformation are increasingly changing public debate. At the same time, the questions societies have to decide on are becoming more complex: climate change, the energy transition, demographic change and artificial intelligence. All of them require knowledge. But what role should we as researchers play in this?
The simple answer is often: science provides the facts, politics decides. That is not wrong – but it falls short.
Science and democracy are not inseparably linked. Science exists and develops in non-democratic states, too. And a democracy must not bind political decisions to scientists. Nevertheless, there is a special reciprocal relationship. An open, democratic society creates a unique space in which scientific evidence, social values and customs, and political responsibility can interact.
Scientific knowledge does not arise from certainty, but from doubt. Research thrives on questioning, testing and correcting. Results must be reproducible, hypotheses may be discarded, and supposed certainties replaced by new findings. This is how we have worked for as long as our disciplines have existed.
This requires the freedom to ask uncomfortable questions, to publish results independently of political or economic pressures and interests, and to contradict other scientific positions. Open societies offer good conditions for this. Academic freedom is therefore more than a privilege for researchers – it is a prerequisite for them to fulfil their role in society.
Herein lies an interesting parallel to democracy. It, too, thrives on criticism, scrutiny and correction. Parliaments, courts, a free press and a vigilant civil society ensure that decisions can be questioned. Democracy and science by no means follow the same rules. But both need open spaces for criticism and dissent.

This difference is crucial. In a democracy, different interests are negotiated. Science cannot take over these decisions.
A climate projection does not automatically lead to the “right” climate policy. Science can show the consequences of emission scenarios. It can quantify and model risks and make trade-offs visible. But how we weigh prosperity, freedom, security, fair distribution or the interests of future generations against one another is something we must decide socially and politically. Political majorities cannot change the realities of nature. Conversely, scientific findings do not give their authors a political mandate. It is precisely this distance that matters. Science should inform politics, not replace it.
But responsibility does not end there. It would be too easy to deliver findings and then withdraw.
Science must explain and contextualise. It must make clear what we know – and what we don’t. It must name uncertainties, counter misinterpretations and make the possible consequences of decisions visible. Above all, it must be able to bear complexity, especially when public debate calls for the simplest possible answers.
We must be close enough to society to remain relevant – and far enough from political interests to remain independent, even when budgets and reputation are at stake. Proximity and distance are not opposites here.
This responsibility also changes the way we do research. Major societal challenges can hardly be understood from the perspective of a single discipline anymore.
We experience this directly at the Helmholtz-Zentrum Hereon. When we study the future of our coasts, for example, it is not enough to look at climate, ecosystems or human use in isolation. We need to bring together measurements and models, environmental sciences and new digital methods and technologies. Digital twins can use this to develop scenarios: What changes when sea levels rise? What are the consequences of different forms of coastal use? Where do conflicting goals arise? What role can green hydrogen – produced with wind energy – play?
Here, too, science expands the room for informed decisions. And society is not merely a recipient in this process. Formats such as citizen science, transdisciplinary research or direct exchange with social actors can bring new perspectives and knowledge into research. This by no means makes us arbitrary. Our findings must still meet quality standards. But the questions we ask and the consequences we consider do not arise in a vacuum.
Perhaps this is precisely one of the strengths of the relationship between science and democracy: it is not a comfortable one.
Science must be independent and at the same time a driving force in society. It must listen without adapting its findings to majorities. It must engage in debates without becoming politics itself. And it must not merely endure criticism, but understand it as part of its pursuit of knowledge. This is exactly where its value lies.
In its perspectives for the science system up to 2040, the German Council of Science and Humanities (Wissenschaftsrat) made clear that, alongside scientific quality, research must also ensure integrity, impact, participation and the responsible use of resources. Science is thus not only a driver of knowledge and innovation. It is also part of the infrastructure of a democratic society.
Such a society needs science that enables it to make better decisions: independent, critical and in constant dialogue. And science needs a society that protects precisely this independence.